Despite the increase of smartphones, digital cameras remain a popular holiday purchase. People of all ages enjoy cameras, especially during this time of the year, surrounded by family and friends. Consumers want to shop and retailers want to entice them. However, competition in this category is high and there are many phones without great differentiators. Below outlines how major retailers found niches in pricing, promotions, or assortment in which they could compete.
Eight top retailers in the digital camera category are compared: Amazon, BestBuy, NewEgg, Walmart, Target, Sears, OfficeMax and OfficeDepot.
Assortment enables retailers to distinguish themselves from their competition – both in the quantity of their products and the price distribution of their assortment.
Amazon – tops for pure assortment count
Living up to its reputation, Amazon has the largest assortment in digital cameras and maintained this by a wide margin throughout the holiday season. Best Buy has the second largest overall assortment. OfficeMax and Office Depot have the smallest assortments.
Through most of the holiday season, Amazon carried 3.2x the assortment of Best Buy. Retailers generally build up inventory leading into a particular shopping season and then let it decrease as the season continues and winds down. Amazon followed that pattern with a decrease in their assortment heading into the final stages of the shopping season. While inventory started to slowly dwindle at the beginning of December, a notable decrease is seen the week before Christmas, December 18th. Despite decreasing its inventory by 761 products, Amazon still has 2.9x the assortment over both Best Buy and New Egg.
Going against this normal pattern, NewEgg actually increased its assortment, starting on December 23rd, even briefly beating out Best Buy for second place status.
Amazon also has the largest percentage of its inventory on discount, plus a fairly even discount bucket spread.
NewEgg- best in premium camera assortment
Instead of competing with Amazon for the largest assortment, NewEgg focused on premium products. Compared to other major electronic retailers, they had the largest percentage of their inventory focused on high end cameras. This strategy helped NewEgg target the digital camera market not met by smartphones. NewEgg had 35% of their inventory (246 items) with a final price over $500 and 20% (119 items) priced between $376-500. In total, they had 55% of all cameras in a premium range.
As part of their focus on premium cameras, NewEgg did not do a lot of discounting. Their average camera discount, with very little variance throughout the season, was 21%; only Sears and OfficeMax had less discounting than NewEgg.
OfficeMax carves a small niche with premium assortment
OfficeMax had the same approach as NewEgg – focus on premium products to compete against smartphones. OfficeMax is a much smaller player in the digital camera category, with only 22 items in total in their inventory. Although they are a minor retailer in this field, they were the only retailer carrying a larger percentage of premium assortment than NewEgg. OfficeMax has 60% of their inventory (13 products total) priced over $500 (compared to NewEgg’s 35% (246 items).
Sears: Overall lowest price
When comparing overall final average prices, Sears had the lowest pricing. $299 was their average final price and 65% of their camera assortment was priced under $250.
Best Buy: Lowest pricing of major digital camera retailers
When comparing the top players in electronics and digital cameras (Amazon, NewEgg, BestBuy), Best Buy came in with the lowest average final price, $412.
Both Sears and BestBuy have maintained this low price position throughout the entire holiday season.
Sears has held the position of lowest pricing despite having the least number of items on discount, relying instead on providing overall lower final prices. As of today, 98% of their products are not on discount. During the entire holiday season they have not had more than 20% of their products on discount at any given time.
Best Buy also relied on EDLP with only 55% of their inventory discounted, compared to 90% of the items on discount at Amazon and 65% at NewEgg.
Target & Walmart: Neck in neck in pricing, assortment, & promotions
Target and Walmart seem to be competing primarily with each other. Their assortment is similar both in quantity and pricing. They adjust their assortment at similar times, and have similar promotions.
Target maintained slightly lower pricing than Walmart during the holiday, while Walmart had lower pricing just after Christmas.
Both had EDLP strategies with less than 50% of their assortment discounted.
Retailers found niches in which they have differentiated themselves in the digital camera category this holiday season:
- Sears had the lowest average prices
- Best Buy was the electronic company with lowest overall pricing
- Amazon had the largest assortment
- NewEgg and OfficeMax compete in premium cameras
- Target & Walmart compete neck in neck with each other only
Sudhir is focused on leading Ugam Solutions’ drive towards actionable insight solutions for the retail industry. He comes with a wealth of knowledge of the retail industry, having over 18 years of consulting experience helping leading retailers improve their digital commerce and supply chain performance. Sudhir has previously worked with Accenture and Infosys, where his last role was to establish and lead the multi-channel commerce practice.